BRIA 21 3 a Dust Bowl Exodus: How Drought and the Depression Took Their Toll

CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS FOUNDATION
Bill of Rights in Action

Summer 2005 (21:3)

Economics and Democracy

BRIA 21:3 Home |  Dust Bowl Exodus | The German Weimar Republic | Outsourcing Jobs to Other Countries

 

Dust Bowl Exodus: How Drought and the Depression Took Their Toll

In the 1930s, in the midst of the Great Depression, many farmers and farm workers left failed farms in the southern Plains for work in California. Suffering from the Depression themselves, Californians had a difficult time dealing with these refugees.

California’s population exploded in the first half of the 20th century. In just 10 years, between 1920 and 1930, more than 2 million people came to find “the good life,” believing that they would make a new start and build a fortune under the state’s sunny skies. The new migrants of the ’20s were mostly middle-class people, including some farmers. They were drawn to a state where opportunity was booming. But things changed in the decade of the ’30s. The stock market crash in October 1929 marked the beginning of the Great Depression. Banks closed, businesses folded, and by 1933 three of 10 Californians were unemployed.

Beginning in the early ’30s, migrants from the states of Oklahoma, Texas, Arkansas, and Missouri came to California in ever-increasing numbers. Farmers, who hired the migrant workers at 20 or 25 cents an hour to pick cotton, oranges, and peas, initially welcomed them. But by the end of the decade, they were the objects of scorn and prejudice.

These migrants were called “Okies.” “Okie” is slang meaning “a person from Oklahoma.” But during the Depression, the term was used to refer to people from states neighboring Oklahoma as well, and it was often used derisively.

Leaving the Southern Plains

The southern Plains experienced a terrible drought during the early 1930s. Intense heat accompanied the drought. In the summer of 1934, Oklahoma reached 117 degrees on July 24, the 36th day in a row that it had been above 100 degrees. Fields and rivers dried up, and clouds of grasshoppers ate what was left of the wheat and corn. According to one Weather Bureau scientist, the drought of the ’30s was “the worst in the climatological history of the country.”

Drought was not the only cause of the westward movement of farmers and sharecroppers from the southern Plains. When prices fell because of oversupply following the end of World War I, many farmers lost their farms and became tenants or sharecroppers. As more and more farms were cultivated with tractors, the tenants and farm laborers lost their jobs, because tractors were much more efficient. And as the soil was tilled and retilled, it lost its fertility. Worn out, it lay naked and unprotected from raging winds.

In 1934, windstorms ravaged the Plains states. The incredible storms sent clouds of dust as far as Chicago, New York, and Boston. In 1935, the storms became even worse. For six weeks in March and early April, it was unusual to see a clear sky from dawn to dusk anywhere in the Plains states. In Kansas, 12 consecutive days of dust storms raged in March. One Kansas resident wrote in her diary: “This is the ultimate darkness. So must come the end of the world.” But in fact, it got worse. On April 14—“ Black Sunday”—a deadly storm turned day into night. The storms resulted in more farms failing and more people out of work. Desperately poor, people began an exodus from the Dust Bowl.

Coming to California

Of the half million people who fled Oklahoma and neighboring states during the Depression years, more than 300,000 went to California. Most were farmers or tenant farmers, and they came to California in search of farm work. One magnet was California’s cotton crop, which had exploded in size. In 1926, California farms planted 170,000 acres of cotton. By 1937, there were 600,000 acres of cotton fields in the San Joaquin Valley alone. Cotton was the state’s fourth largest crop. California’s cotton growers desperately needed trained pickers, and many people from the southern Plains had picked cotton for years. News of the new bumper crop lured people west on Highway 66.

Many stopped in Arizona to pick cotton. Following Route 66, they headed to California’s San Joaquin Valley and joined earlier migrants, who were camping on ditch banks or in vacant lots outside the towns. After the fall cotton harvest, they had little or no income (except welfare, then known as “relief”) until May, when the potato crop was ready for harvest. In the summer, many drove their jalopies north to the Sacramento Valley to pick citrus, peaches, grapes, and peas. To earn a living, they traveled for six to nine months a year. But while some did reasonably well, and a few earned as much as $1,600 in a year, the median family income in 1940 was $650. (The median family income for other white Californians in the San Joaquin Valley was $1,510.)

Even for those who did not travel, living conditions were ghastly. The new migrants pitched tents along irrigation ditches or on the side of a road close to a spring of water. Some built houses out of corrugated paper tacked to wooden frames. Most camps had no toilets and no clean water. Public health officials grew alarmed. Outbreaks of smallpox, tuberculosis, malaria, and pneumonia were common in the camps.

Journalists and activists who visited the squatters’ camps described what they saw. An article in the San Francisco Chronicle in 1937 told about conditions in Kern County camps where “migrants live in almost unimaginable [sic] filth . . . “ The Berkeley Gazette reported on “hungry ‘Dust Bowl’ refugees . . . living in the fields and woods ‘like animals.’ ”

From Welcome to Hostility—and Worse

In the early ’30s, owners of large farms had feared an inadequate labor supply. They had relied on Mexican laborers. These laborers had come north after the Mexican Revolution of 1910 and subsequent unrest in Mexico. But in the 1930s, many Mexican laborers began returning to Mexico because of the Depression, stability in Mexico, and prejudice against them. Many of the remaining Mexican field workers were beginning to organize into unions and go on strike in the fields. The arrival of the refugees from the Dust Bowl calmed the growers’ fears of a labor shortage. And the new arrivals, who were penniless and not yet eligible for state relief, were willing to accept lower wages than Mexican laborers.

Unlike the Mexican farm workers, the refugees from the Plains did not disappear when the harvest season ended. Nor did they spread themselves throughout the state. Because they came to work on farms and had hopes of getting a farm of their own, most settled in farming counties. They soon began converting squatter camps into “Little Oklahomas” around many of the valley’s older towns. The new arrivals required health services, and their only recourse was to seek aid at county-supported public hospitals. They had children who needed schooling. It cost public money to provide for them, and as tax rates began to rise, long-term residents blamed the migrants.

From 1935 to 1938, as the migration continued to increase, the problems experienced in the farming counties were largely ignored in the rest of California. But floods came to the San Joaquin Valley in early 1938 washing out ditch banks and leaving the migrants cold, sick and hungry. Journalists recorded the horrible conditions, and suddenly the migrants were headline news.

A new federal law cut back cotton acreage from 618,000 to under 400,000 acres. The cut in acreage meant less demand for agricultural labor. And the floods ruined other crops as well. There were now “ten pickers to every pea in the pod,” and panic spread throughout the state. The sea of antagonism continued to rise. The Dust Bowl migrants were portrayed as “shiftless trash who live like hogs” and accused of “stealing jobs” from native Californians.

How the New Deal Helped and Hurt

The Depression that began in 1929 created suffering throughout California. In 1933, the unemployment rate in Los Angeles was 33 percent. Banks were locking doors, and people stuffed what money they had under their mattresses. When Franklin Roosevelt was elected president in 1932, he spoke in his first inaugural address of the grim reality that faced the nation: a time when “the withered leaves of industrial enterprise lie on every side; farmers find no markets for their produce; the savings of many years in thousands of families are gone.”

To address the devastation of the Depression, the Roosevelt administration introduced and passed social-welfare legislation that came to be known as the “New Deal.” Bills were passed providing workers with a right to bargain collectively (the National Labor Relations Act); minimum wage and maximum hour protection (the Wage and Hours Bill), and support in old age (the Social Security Act). But farm laborers received none of these benefits. They were exempted from each of these acts because of pressure from farming states.

One piece of New Deal legislation even contributed to the hardship of farm workers. In an effort to control farm prices, the Agricultural Administration passed a law in 1933 that paid farmers to withdraw land from cultivation in return for cash payments. According to the law, the farmers were supposed to share the payments they received with their tenants and sharecroppers. But most of them kept the money for themselves. And with fewer acres being farmed, more and more tenants and croppers were evicted. “I let ’em all go,” said one Oklahoma farmer. “I bought tractors on the money my government gave me and got shet o’ [rid of] my renters.”

The New Deal made attempts to alleviate the distress of rural workers. In 1933, Congress passed the Federal Emergency Relief Act (FERA), which gave grants to states “to aid needy persons who have no legal settlement in any one State or Community.” By 1935, over 200,000 migrating poor families received federal aid, and California was the state most dependent on FERA funds. With funds from the Farm Security Administration, the State Emergency Relief Administration also began a migrant housing program. In 1935, two model camps were built, in Marysville and Arvin. The camps provided tents, one-room cabins, and most important, buildings with toilets and showers. But with room for only 400 families, the camps did not come close to solving the hideous living conditions of most migrant workers. And in August 1935, the federal government shut down the federal Transient Service, which had been the sole source of cash relief to unemployed migrant workers during their first year in California. For migrants who had depended on federal relief, all that was left was state relief—and that was available only after they had lived in the state for one year.

“Anti-Okie” Hysteria Explodes

When the federal government discontinued cash aid to transients in 1935, Californians began to worry about the wave of indigent migrants. The panic was particularly fierce in Los Angeles. In February 1936, Police Chief James Davis dispatched an “expeditionary force” of 150 police officers to points along the border with orders to enforce a “bum blockade.” Mayor Frank Shaw defended the legality of the blockade, declaring that Los Angeles “would not be the dumping ground of charity seekers.”

The “bum blockade” garnered attention, and criticism, throughout the state and nation. After the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed suit in federal court, Chief Davis backed down, and the “bum blockade” ended. But the “anti-Okie” sentiment continued. Three years later, in 1939, police in the Central Valley counties began arresting migrants under a law that made it a crime to knowingly bring an indigent person into the state. One person arrested under the indigent law was a lay preacher named Fred Edwards. He was arrested for driving his brother-in-law, Frank Duncan, from Texas to California. After he had been tried and convicted, the ACLU came to his defense and filed an appeal that was eventually heard by the U.S. Supreme Court.

In Edwards v. California, the court ruled unanimously that California’s indigent act (and similar laws in 27 other states) was unconstitutional. But the court was divided on the basis for its ruling. The majority opinion held that the law violated the interstate commerce clause, by interfering with the free movement of people.

Four other justices agreed that the law was unconstitutional, but for different reasons. In a concurring opinion, Justice William O. Douglas wrote that the right of people to move freely “occupies a more protected position in our constitutional system than does the movement of cattle, fruit and steel and coal across state lines.” Because the right to move freely from state to state is a right of national citizenship, Douglas invoked the privileges and immunities clause of the 14th Amendment. It provides that “No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges and immunities of citizens of the United States.” (Justice Douglas was joined by Justices Black and Murphy.)

Justice Robert H. Jackson also invoked the privileges and immunities clause. Indigence alone, he said, cannot be used by a state to limit a person’s rights as a citizen. “We should say now, and in no uncertain terms,” Jackson wrote, “that a man’s mere property status, without more, cannot be used by a state to test, qualify, or limit his rights as a citizen of the United States . . .. I think California had no right to make the condition of Duncan’s purse . . . the basis of excluding him or of punishing one who extended him aid.”

In 1837, the U.S. Supreme Court had referred to the poor as a “moral pestilence.” The Edwards case marked a significant departure from the prejudice against paupers and vagrants. But by the time the opinion was issued in early 1941, the migrant farm workers’ problems had begun to disappear.

A Happier Time

Although relatively few Americans paid attention to the plight of the Dust Bowl migrants during the early ’30s, a small group of reformers was documenting the problems in the fields and squatters’ camps. Two, in particular, brought the issue to national attention. One was a photographer, named Dorothea Lange, whom the Resettlement Administration had hired to document the lives of farm workers. The San Francisco News published Lange’s photographs in 1936 under the headline, “Ragged Hungry, Broke, Harvest Workers Live In Squalor.” Another of her photos published later that year—the “Migrant Mother”—became one of the most famous photographs of American history.

Also in 1936, the San Francisco News published a series of articles titled the “Harvest Gypsies,” which depicted the plight of the migrant farm workers in excruciating detail. The articles were written by John Steinbeck, a novelist who had became concerned about the problem and spent months during 1936 living with the farm workers in the ditch banks and the FSA camps. Two years later, Steinbeck transformed the documentary material into a novel, The Grapes of Wrath, which within a few weeks became the nation’s bestseller. The Grapes of Wrath, which also became an immensely popular movie, recounted the lives of the fictional Joad family, as they moved from Oklahoma to California and struggled to survive in the fields.

Lange’s photographs and The Grapes of Wrath created a storm of publicity and focused the nation’s attention on the problem of migrant farm workers. The president sent emissaries to visit the camps, and Eleanor Roosevelt herself came to California for five days to visit with the migrants and talk to Californians about their migrant problem. Congress established the Select Committee to Investigate the Interstate Migration of Destitute Citizens. In 1940, the committee held hearings around the country and collected yet more evidence about the problems of the migrants.

But developments elsewhere in the world made the committee’s work almost irrelevant. In March 1939, Germany’s Adolf Hitler invaded Czechoslovakia. In September, he invaded Poland, and Britain and France declared war. Ill-prepared for war, Britain and France urgently needed American airplanes and weapons. Thus began a program of military preparedness that brought with it new prosperity and employment. As the defense boom gained momentum, many of the migrants left the farms and went into the cities for work.

Because the migrants were able to get new jobs in the cities, fewer remained on the farms. Those who stayed were needed as workers. By the end of World War II, the “Okies” were assimilated into California. It was war—not the New Deal—that solved their problem.

For Discussion

1.         What were some of the causes for people living in the Dust Bowl to leave and head for California?

2.         What social and economic impact did these people have on California?

3.         What was the case of Edwards v. California? What did the court agree and disagree on? Which opinion do you most agree with? Why?

4.         What problems of poverty do you see today in the United States? What, if anything, do you think should be done about these problems?

A C T I V I T YArtists of the 1930s

John Steinbeck and Dorothea Lange were among the many artists working in the 1930s. Below is a sampling of more. Choose an artist (or artists) and create a report that explains (1) what the artist(s) did, (2) what works the artist(s) created in the ’30s, and (3) how the artist(s) reflected the conditions of the times. If possible, exhibit a sample of the work of the artist(s).

James AgeeFred Allen

Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers

Jack Benny

Thomas Hart Benton

Edgar Bergen

Busby Berkeley

Gutzon Borglum

George Burns and Gracie Allen

Erskine Caldwell

Frank Capra

Charlie Chaplin

Walt Disney

Tommy Dorsey

John Dos Passos

Duke Ellington

James T. Farrell

William Faulkner

W.C. Fields

John Ford

George and Ira Gershwin

Benny Goodman

Woody Guthrie

Dashiell Hammett

Fletcher Henderson

Edward Hopper

Ernest Hemingway

Zora Neale Hurston

George S. Kaufman

Dorothea Lange

Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy

Marx Brothers

Johnny Mercer

Margaret Mitchell

Clifford Odets

Paul Robeson

John Steinbeck

Orson Welles

Mae West

Thomas Wolfe

Grant Wood

 

For Further Information

The Great Depression

Encyclopedia Articles:

Encarta: The Great Depression

Wikipedia: The Great Depression

Columbia Encyclopedia: The Great Depression

Answers.com: The Great Depression

Citizendium: The Great Depression

Economic History Services Encyclopedia: An Overview of the Great Depression

The Great Depression An overview of the Depression and Dust Bowl. Compiled and prepared by Cary Nelson.

The Great Crash and the Great Slump An essay by economist J. Bradford DeLong, University of California at Berkeley.

Main Causes of the Great Depression By Paul Alexander Gusmorino III.

American History 102: Crashing Hopes: The Great Depression Lecture by Stanley K. Schultz, professor of history, University of Wisconsin.

Internet Modern History Sourcebook: The Great Depression Links to primary source documents.

Directory Links:

Google Directory: The Great Depression

Open Directory Project: The Great Depression

Yahoo Directory: The Great Depression

The Dust Bowl

Encyclopedia Articles:

            Encarta: The Dust Bowl

            Wikipedia: The Dust Bowl

            Columbia Encyclopedia: The Dust Bowl

            Answers.com: The Dust Bowl

Economic History Encyclopedia: The Dust Bowl

Time Magazine: “Worse Than 1934” A 1936 report on conditions in the Dust Bowl.

PBS: Surviving the Dust Bowl

Sparknotes: The Dust Bowl

The Library of Congress: The Dust Bowl

Living History Farm: The Dust Bowl

The New Criterion: Steinbeck's Myth of the Okies

Dust Bowl Exodus Time line 

Directory Links:

            Google Directory: The Dust Bowl

            Open Directory Project: The Dust Bowl

            Yahoo Directory: The Dust Bowl

Kansas History Website: Dust Bowl

Dust Bowl Migrants in California

American Diaspora: Dust Bowl migration, 1930–1940

Library of Congress: American Memory: The Migrant Experience

Library of Congress: American Memory: Voices From the Dust Bowl

“The Dust Bowl Migration”: Poverty Stories, Race Stories An essay by James N. Gregory.

New Deal and Farm Relief 

Wikipedia articles:

The New Deal’s Farm Programs

The Agricultural Adjustment Act of 1933

Farm Security Administration

Civilian Conservation Corps

The Resettlement Administration

Soil Conservation Service

Answers.com articles:

            New Deal Farm Programs

            The Agricultural Adjustment Act of 1933

            Farm Security Administration

            Civilian Conservation Corps.

LivingHistoryFarms:New Deal Farm Laws This site offers a comprehensive examination of all of the farm programs that the New Deal oversaw.

New Deal Network An educational guide to the Great Depression of the 1930s, sponsored by the Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt Institute.

Kingwood College Library: American Cultural History 1930–1939

PBS American Experience: New Deal Remedies for Dust Bowl Sufferers

Edwards v. California (1941)

Oyez:U.S. Supreme Court Media: Edwards v. California The facts and holding of the case.

Wikipedia: Edwards v. California

L.A. Times: LAPD Blocked Dust Bowl Migrants at State Borders A 2003 article on the LAPD’s policy during the Depression.

Text of the case:

FindLaw: Edwards v. California

Justia: Edwards v. California

            University of Missouri-Kansas School of Law: Edwards v. California

Dorothea Lange

Encyclopedia Articles:

Encarta: Dorothea Lange

Wikipedia: Dorothea Lange

Columbia Encyclopedia: Dorothea Lange

Answers.com: Dorothea Lange

Oakland Museum Collections: Dorothea Lange

History Place: Pictures and Original Captions of Dorothea Lange

Library of Congress: Dorothea Lange

Google Images: Dorothea Lange

Links:

Google Directory: Dorothea Lange

Open Directory Project: Dorothea Lange

Yahoo Directory: Dorothea Lange

John Steinbeck and The Grapes of Wrath

Encyclopedia Articles on Steinbeck:

Encarta: John Steinbeck

Wikipedia: John Steinbeck

Columbia Encyclopedia: John Steinbeck

Answers.com: John Steinbeck

Citizendium: John Steinbeck

Encyclopedia Articles on The Grapes of Wrath:

            Wikipedia: The Grapes of Wrath 

            Answers.com: The Grapes of Wrath

            Citizendium: The Grapes of Wrath

Study Guides to The Grapes of Wrath:

SparkNotes: The Grapes of Wrath

ClassicNote: The Grapes of Wrath

BookWolf: The Grapes of Wrath

Pink Monkey: The Grapes of Wrath

Cliffs Notes: The Grapes of Wrath

PBS: The American Novel: The Grapes of Wrath A short review of the novel and a video clip from the film.

C-SPAN: American Writers II: John Steinbeck 

Western Washington University: The Grapes of Wrath

Time Magazine’s 100 Best Novels: The Grapes of Wrath The original review of the book.

NPR: Present at the Creation: The Grapes of Wrath A 2002 report on the book with links to many resources.

Steinbeck: The California Novels A great set of resources and links to more.

National Steinbeck Center

Ball State University: John Steinbeck Collection

Center for Steinbeck Studies A comprehensive and authorized resource for readers, students, teachers, and scholars of John Steinbeck.

A Research Guide for Students: The Grapes of Wrath

FilmSite: The Grapes of Wrath A detailed review of the 1940 film, which was based on the book.

Weedpatch Camp The camp that Steinbeck visited and based the camp in the book on.

Links:

Google Directory:

The Grapes of Wrath

John Steinbeck

Open Directory Project:

The Grapes of Wrath

John Steinbeck

Yahoo Directory:

The Grapes of Wrath

John Steinbeck

Books

American Exodus: The Dust Bowl Migration and Okie Culture in California By James N. Gregory.

Route 66 in California By Glen Duncan.

The Worst Hard Time: The Untold Story of Those Who Survived the Great American Dust Bowl By Timothy Egan.

Reapers of the Dust: A Prairie Chronicle By Lois Phillips Hudson.

The Dust Bowl: An Agricultural and Social History By R. Douglas Hurt.

Heaven's Tableland: The Dust Bowl Story By Vance Johnson.

American Exodus: A Record of Human Erosion By Dorothea Lange and Paul S. Taylor.

Dust Bowl Diary By Ann Marie Low.

Factories in the Field: The Story of Migratory Farm Labor in California By Carey McWilliams.

Rooted in Dust: Surviving Drought and Depression in Southwestern Kansas By Pamela Riney-Kehrberg.

Endangered Dreams: The Great Depression in California By Kevin Starr.

California and the Dust Bowl Migration By Walter J. Stein.

“Their Blood Is Strong” By John Steinbeck.

The Grapes of Wrath A novel by John Steinbeck.

Farming the Dust Bowl: A First-Hand Account from Kansas By Lawrence Svobida,

Dust Bowl: A Problem-Based Unit By Joyce Van Tassel-Baska

The Hungry Years: A Narrative History of the Great Depression in America By T.H. Watkins.

Dust Bowl: The Southern Plains in the 1930s By Donald Worster.

Americans View Their Dust Bowl Experience Edited by John R. Wunder, Frances W. Kaye, and Vernon Carstensen.

The Dust Bowl: Men, Dirt, and Depression By Paul Bonnifield.

Pictures

“Migrant Mother” By Dorothea Lange.

Wind Erosion Research Unit: Dust Bowl Pictures Including a Dust Bowl Region Map. From the U.S. Department of Agriculture and Kansas State University.

Walter Stiern Library: Dust Bowl Photographs From California State University, Bakersfield.

Library of Congress: America From the Great Depression to World War II

 

Our Major Sponsors

directv       toyotalogo     20thcenturyfox  

  cbsg     disney   gibsundunn  omelveny   mungertolles    sheppardmullin   skadden     edisoninternational       weil      discovery     greenberg      katten      kirkland     msk-res-2-01   proskauer    sidleyaustin  arnold_porter  bryancave    crowell     dechert  dentons     littler  morganlewis  orick  scripps  strozfried  bbwalmartwhitecase   wilmerhale


  barnesthornburg  mcguriewoods cornerstone